For being a counter-revolutionary pyramid scheme
For co-opting our movements for recruitment
For targeting vulnerable young people with cult tactics
CARF: Campaign Against Racism and Fascism
Uni Students For Climate Justice
Students for Palestine Adelaide
Red Flag (their newspaper)
Marxism Conference (their national conference)
We desperately need genuine radical resistance to oppose settler-colonialism, capitalism, liberalism, and the military-industrial complex. SAlt will not and cannot provide this because of the way that they organize - they will burn you out and keep records on you that make us incapable of building an effective resistance. Take this as an invitation to join the swamp and fight for the liberated world we can all enjoy!
Building a Better World Should Mean: | The Way SAlt Operates: |
---|---|
mutual aid | funelling millions of $$$ to who the fuck even knows |
solidarity between groups | speaking over existing groups |
openness to criticism and improvement | shutting down criticism |
direct action | purely symbolic "actions" (recruitment front) |
decolonization | adherance to settler-colonial hegemony |
intersectionality | co-opting causes like free palestine for recruitment |
strong communities of care | seperating recruits from their community |
privacy and anonymity | recording peoples' personal details |
Our goal is revolution, and SAlt's organizing practices are an obstacle to that end because of the reasons we'll outline below. Be like water, dissolve SAlt and become more useful revolutionaries!
please do not harass anyone just for being a member of SAlt - we are against the structure, not necessarily the people who make up the structure.
Over the past 18 months, we have come face-to-face with socialist groups at events we have organised in Melbourne and Brisbane. WAR have not once had a positive experience with the Social Alliance or the Socialist Alternative (SAlt). (cont.)
âIn the long term, members of SAlt have repeatedly submitted motions to council that attempt to speak for First Nations people, their lived experience [sic] and the particular oppression which they face both in so called âAustraliaâ and internationally, without any consultation with the Indigenous Office Bearers or Indigenous Rep on Council,â Deverall said.
We organised a rally as part of a grassroots anti-poverty group and a SAlt member asked if they could speak at it. Knowing what theyâre like, some of us were not keen on the idea but others wanted to give them another chance so we made it clear to them that they werenât welcome to sell their paper/merch or to recruit there. On the day I was standing further up the steps of parliament than others and I could see very clearly SAlties on the periphery of the crowd selling papers to people and getting their details, I canât really give them the benefit of the doubt either because before they took payment, they looked around to make sure no one saw them. They had their board of badges there too. Also, when the SAltie spoke they took way more time with their heated speech than they were told they could have.
Though I was pursuing the organisation out of interest and free will, I still had limited capacity to rebuff their offers. When pressed about my attendance at an upcoming âMarxism Conferenceâ for example, my response â that I would probably be occupied with family Easter celebrations â was met with the unsympathetic retort that â[I could] do family things every yearâ.
- Indicates a strong pressure to give up time and ties to family in favour of SAlt. This is a common tactic of cults, requiring people to dedicate more and more time to the cult, which cuts off family and makes it harder to escape.
(SAlt thinks) Anarchists (are): people with drug problems and whose beliefs led to the Franco regime.
wow huh. what's wrong with drug users?
In spite of increasing, yet still private, disillusionment, I left Melbourne with a membership card. It was at this point I was informed of âduesâ I would have to pay in proportion to my income. This was justified to Honi as âlike any union or political party.â
Springing membership fees on them after they had already joined, because they're less likely to refuse then, is manipulative. Also, not all unions or political parties pay dues. Many of them don't. It's altogether possible to run a powerful resistance org without financial income.
Interestingly, however, I heard rumours, fitting with my experience of a highly stratified organisation, that some members were afforded a stipend of sorts from the organisation. Socialist Alternative denied this to Honi.
Cults and pyramid schemes often have this highly stratified organisational structure. Many leftist organisations, including even state communists like Marxist-Leninist groups, don't operate in this way.
Though their constitution spells out quite clearly that âmembers may resign at any time by communicating their resignation to any body of the organisationâ I had heard different stories. Iâd read student publications describing harassment. Iâd spoken to friends, some old and some new, who relayed personal experiences of vitriol, spitting, and physical intimidation. Iâd been told of an ex-member receiving unstamped death threats in their mailbox. Reassuringly, they denied this to Honi.
- This is extremely common across many cults. Scientology, for example, is famous for harassing and monitoring ex-members for years.
a young female member, with whom I was hardly acquainted, randomly asked me on a date.
Cults often expect members to date and live with other members.
Here are some excerpts:
Even today, members will see me in the street and say things to draw a reaction from me. Once you leave, they turn on you.
after I experienced such grievances myself, I reported them, and no action was ever taken. They promptly ignored all criticism in order to maintain social order within the group.
All organisations need grievance processes, or else there's no way for them to tell how to improve.
I was shunned and verbally abused by a member, Lawrence, for saying, âCatching a bus to Adelaide from my house is a bitch of a journeyâ. After being a member for so long, your entire vocabulary begins to change, to mould into what is accepted within the organisation, else you face abuse and/or discipline.
While changing your vocab to be more inclusive and respectful is admirable, shutting-down peoples' ability to express themselves is a classic cult tactic, making people unable to express disagreement and alienating people from broader society.
Ex-SAlt member told to lie to family to pay for dues. Likely to separate them from their non-SAlt support network.
I was recruited by SAlt when I was 17, it was my first protest in Adelaide and they drew me in with very luke warm marxist slogans but I was young and hadn't established as much in my revolutionary praxis yet. They kept bugging me to buy their shitty news paper and I told them over and over "I'm between a safehouse in domestic violence protection, couch surfing and living on the streets...I don't have $5 to feed myself let alone buy a newspaper" and they continued to berate and victim blaim me. They managed to convince me to go to their hideout in rundle mall and I was mobalising with a cane at the time, they had a shitty rundown elevator that looked like it was going to break off the lines and berated me further for not being able to "just use the stairs, you can walk" then when I sat down in the meeting they just breathed down my neck and tried to assign me busy work which I informed them was not doable for me as I have a deadly heart condition and manual labour could literaly kill me, they continued to berate me. I finally wised up by that point and managed to lose them in the alleys after they continuiosly followed me and I then realised that I had left my bag in their hideout, when I tried to retreive it quietly they stopped me in the street and forced me to hand out flyers without anywhere to sit down and then bribed me with my belongings being like "oh come do this and then we can get your bag" this lead ro three seperate tasks and I eventually just abandoned my bag and got as far away from them as physically possble, as soon as I was alone I had a panic attack and realised just how much I'd lost by losing my bag. It was all I really owned at the time and I greived a lot for a while
Site by a group of anonymous, proud swampies, hheeheheheh.
Contact diton.avantgarde@proton.me if you want anything added or removed.
We can give you more secure comms if needed.